Black Stone Minerals: Safe 7% Distribution Despite Subordinated Conversion - Sure Dividend Sure Dividend

Sure Dividend

High Quality Dividend Stocks, Long-Term Plan
Get Top 10 Stocks in Sure Dividend Newsletter NowGet The 5%+ Yield Sure Retirement Newsletter Now

Black Stone Minerals: Safe 7% Distribution Despite Subordinated Conversion


Published by Nick McCullum on July 14th, 2017

Master limited partnerships are fantastic vehicles for generating meaningful portfolio income.

By avoiding tax at the organizational level in exchange for paying out most of their income as unitholder distributions, these investment vehicles create more unitholder income for each dollar of corporate profit.

For this reason, MLPs appeal to retirees and other income investors. This MLP List contains pertinent investment information on all 134 publicly traded master limited partnerships.

Black Stone Minerals (BSM) is a master limited partnership that holds particular investment appeal because of its remarkably high dividend yield of 7%+. This makes Black Stone Minerals one of the very few securities with 5%+ yields in today’s market. The High Dividend Stocks List contains a comprehensive database of all stocks with 5%+ dividend yields (including Black Stone Minerals).

Black Stone Minerals’ high dividend yield and tax-advantaged distribution payments make it an appealing security for income investors.

But, as with any high yield security, due diligence should be performed to ensure the safety of this security’s distribution payments.

This article will analyze the investment prospects and distribution safety of Black Stone Minerals in detail.

Business Overview

Black Stone Minerals is a master limited partnership that owns oil and natural gas mineral rights and royalty interests across much of the domestic United States.

The partnership is the largest publicly traded vehicle focused on oil and gas mineral and royalty interests with a market capitalization of $3.1 billion.

In aggregate, Black Stone Minerals has an interest in more than 18 million energy-rich acres across more than 40 states and 60 producing basins. The partnership does not own a 100% interest in each of its projects. Instead, it has a weighted average ownership interest of ~45%, which allows it to have higher diversification.

BSM Black Stone Minerals At A Glance

Source: Black Stone Minerals 2017 Annual Meeting Presentation, slide 3

Black Stone Minerals is much younger as a publicly-traded security than most of the investments analyzed on Sure Dividend.

The company completed its initial public offering on May 6, 2015, issuing 22.5 million common units at a price of $19 per unit. All said, the IPO raised $401 million of share capital for Black Stone Minerals.

For context, that same security is currently trading at $15.99, which means it has been a very poor investment for the IPO investors. With that said, the future appears brighter than the partnership’s short history as a public security.

And, it’s important to remember that Black Stone Minerals operated privately for decades prior to its IPO.

This long private operating history has allowed the partnership to accumulated a geographically diversified asset base, with exposure to many of the most important energy regions in the United States.

Notably, Black Stone Minerals has exposure to the Bakken Formation, the Marcellus Formation, the Permian Basin, and the Eagle Ford Shale Formation.

A detailed map of Black Stone Minerals’ operations can be seen below.

BSM Black Stone Minerals Large, Diversified Portfolio of Assets

Source: Black Stone Minerals 2017 Annual Meeting Presentation, slide 5

Current Events & Growth Prospects

Black Stone Minerals recently reported financial performance for the first quarter of fiscal 2017.

All said, it was business as usual and the partnership is expecting a record year for fiscal 2017. In the two years since the partnership’s 2015 IPO, Black Stone Minerals has meaningfully grown its production.

2017 is expected to be more of the same, with production expected to grow 14% at the mid-point of 2017 production guidance.

BSM Black Stone Minerals Strong Start to 2017

Source: Black Stone Minerals 2017 Annual Meeting Presentation, slide 10

Black Stone Minerals’ future growth is expected to be heavily reliant on acquisitions. This is in-line with the partnership’s historical growth strategy.

The partnership is a serial acquire of complete and partial interests in oil and energy assets across the United States. And, now that is it a publicly-traded security, it has a new source of capital (common stock) that it can tap to raise funds for acquisitions.

BSM Black Stone Minerals Long History of Acquisitions

Source: Black Stone Minerals 2017 Annual Meeting Presentation, slide 7

Unfortunately, Black Stone Minerals’ fundamental performance since its IPO has been short of the partnership’s expectations.

Reduced cash flows relative to prior expectations have brought the protective mechanisms of Black Stone Minerals’ subordinated units into play. Accordingly, the distribution on Black Stone Minerals subordinated units has been cut. This also means that the subordinated units will be converted into common units.

What does this mean for existing investors in Black Stone Minerals common units?

It is not likely to impair the distribution safety of Black Stone common units.

The reason for this is the conversion ratio. The partnership’s management and board released a public statement in February stating that the subordinated units may convert at a ratio of less than one-to-one to promote continued growth of the common unit’s distribution.

BSM Black Stone Minerals Current Situation BSM

Source: Black Stone Minerals 2017 Annual Meeting Presentation, slide 21

Readers may be wondering why the subordinated units exist at all. After all, all else being equal, a simpler capital structure is generally preferable from an analytical point of view.

The subordinated units were originally put in place as the primary mechanism to minimize dilution of the legacy unitholders at the time of Black Stone Minerals’ IPO. Additional details can be read below.

BSM Black Stone Minerals Subordination Background or Rationale

Source: Black Stone Minerals 2017 Annual Meeting Presentation, slide 20

The timeline for the conversion of Black Stone Minerals’ subordinated units is not set in stone.

If the partnership earns and pays $1.35 in common and subordinated unit distributions for the four-quarter period ending March 31, 2019, then the subordinated units will automatically be converted on a one-to-one basis.

If this net income & distribution threshold is not met, then a later optional conversion may take place at a conversion ratio calculated based on distributions paid. The full equation can be seen in the following slide.

BSM Black Stone Minerals Subordinated Conversion Mechanics

Source: Black Stone Minerals 2017 Annual Meeting Presentation, slide 17

After the subordinated unit conversion, Black Stone Minerals’ management team is expecting 4% per year distribution growth. Any shortfall in these projections could be absorbed by maintaining a similar post-conversion distribution growth rate.

In addition, there is potential for additional growth based on a recovery in commodity prices, which we view to be extremely likely.

BSM Black Stone Minerals Post-Conversion Distribution Growth

Source: Black Stone Minerals 2017 Annual Meeting Presentation, slide 18

All said, the major drivers of Black Stone Minerals’ growth will be incremental acquisitions and the pending conversion of its subordinated units into common units.

Competitive Advantage & Recession Performance

Black Stone Minerals’ competitive advantage comes from owning interests in some of the most desirable energy regions in the United States.

They are also the largest pure-play oil and natural gas mineral rights and royalty interests MLP, which gives them a size-based competitive advantage over their smaller, financially weaker peers.

Black Stone Minerals was not a publicly-traded investment vehicle at the time of the last economic downturn.

As such, it can be difficult to assess the partnership’s ability to endure through future recessions.

With that said, investors should appreciate the company’s conservative financing structure. The partnership has only one source of debt (a senior credit facility) and has a leverage ratio of 1.4x, which is very low for an MLP.

From a cash flow perspective, Black Stone Minerals is 80% hedged against movements in natural gas prices and 70% headed against movements in oil prices, which insulates this partnership from the majority of the effects of movements in commodity prices.

BSM Black Stone Minerals Solid Financial Position

Source: Black Stone Minerals 2017 Annual Meeting Presentation, slide 11

Black Stone Minerals also has one of the safest dividends of any partnership I have analyzed, at least for its common units.

In the most recent quarter, Black Stone Minerals reported a common unit distribution coverage ratio of 2.4x, the highest I have seen in an MLP.

After including the partnership’s subordinated units, Black Stone Minerals had a distribution coverage ratio of 1.5x for all classes of units.

This indicates that even if the subordinated units are converted on a one-to-one basis (the highest conversion possible), Black Stone Minerals’ distribution will still be well-covered.

Valuation & Expected Total Returns

As a master limited partnership, Black Stone Minerals makes extensive use of non-GAAP financial metrics such as distributable cash flow and funds from operations because of the significant non-cash depreciation and amortization charges that its operations incur.

Accordingly, the valuation of this investment vehicle cannot be meaningfully analyzed using typical valuation metrics such as the price-to-earnings ratio.

The most useful and practical alternative to traditional valuation metrics is to compare the partnership’s current dividend yield to its long-term historical average dividend yield.

Black Stone Minerals currently pays a quarterly distribution of $0.2875 per unit which yields 7.2% on the partnership’s current stock price of $16.03.

The following diagram compares Black Stone Minerals’ current dividend yield to its long-term historical average.

BSM Black Stone Minerals Distribution Yield History

Source: YCharts

Black Stone Minerals’ current valuation is above its average valuation since the partnership’s inception in 2015.

While its corporate history to date has been short, it appears that Black Stone Minerals is trading at a reasonable valuation today.

And, even ~3% long-term per-unit growth (remember, the partnership is expecting 4%) gives investors the possibility of achieving double-digit total returns thanks to Black Stone Minerals’ 7%+ dividend yield.

Final Thoughts

Black Stone Minerals’ master limited partnership organizational structure and 7%+ distribution yield help it to immediately stand out to income investors.

Due diligence reveals that the partnership is the largest pure-play MLP in the oil and natural gas mineral rights and royalty interests industry, and has one of the safest distribution I have seen among MLPs.

Accordingly, this partnership holds appeal for conservative high-yield investors.


See Our Best ideas
Get Top 10 Stocks in Sure Dividend Newsletter NowGet The 5%+ Yield Sure Retirement Newsletter Now