Monthly Dividend Stock In Focus: Hugoton Royalty Trust - Sure Dividend

Sure Dividend

High-Quality Dividend Stocks, Long-Term Plan
The Sure Dividend Investing MethodMember's Area

Monthly Dividend Stock In Focus: Hugoton Royalty Trust


Updated on December 28th, 2022 by Aristofanis Papadatos

Hugoton Royalty Trust (HGTXU) has a high dividend yield of 16.7% based on the total distributions of $0.35 per unit in 2022. This places Hugoton on the high dividend stocks list. You can see all 200+ 5%+ yielding stocks here. Hugoton also pays dividends on a monthly schedule, which means investors receive their dividends more frequently than the traditional quarterly schedule.

There are 50 monthly dividend stocks. You can see our complete list of monthly dividend stocks, with important financial metrics like dividend yields, price-to-earnings ratios, and payout ratios, by clicking on the link below:

Royalty trusts have unique characteristics and risk factors, which investors should consider before investing. But they could be appealing for income investors thanks to their high yields. Also, investors looking for exposure to the oil and gas industry may find them attractive.
This article will discuss the business model of Hugoton, and why investors anticipating higher oil and gas prices may want to give this royalty trust a closer look.

Business Overview

Hugoton Royalty Trust was formed on December 1, 1998, when XTO Energy conveyed 80% net profits interests in specific predominantly gas-producing properties in Kansas, Oklahoma and Wyoming to the trust. Net profits are calculated by subtracting production costs, development costs, and labor costs from revenues.

Source: Annual Report 2021 

When all these costs exceed revenues, the trust does not pay any distribution to unitholders. This means that Hugoton does not offer any distribution to its unitholders during periods of low prices of natural gas or high development costs. Hugoton is a small-cap stock, with a market capitalization of only $84 million.

Hugoton has a key difference from other well-known oil and gas trusts, such as Sabine Royalty Trust (SBR) and Cross Timbers Royalty Trust (CRT), as it is primarily a gas producer. In 2021, gas comprised 88% of the production of Hugoton while oil comprised the remaining 12%. As a result, Hugoton is extremely sensitive to the gyrations of the price of natural gas.

Moreover, just like the other well-known oil and gas trusts, Hugoton is negatively affected by the natural decline of its producing wells in the long run. During the last three years, its total production has declined by 5% per year on average. This is a strong headwind for future growth prospects.

The most recent forecasts are for remaining reserves of 120.5 million cubic feet of gas and 1.5 million barrels of oil. Given this level of proved reserves of Hugoton and its current production rate, the trust has an estimated life of reserves of roughly 10-11 years. However, investors should be aware that the estimated life of reserves significantly changes with gas prices, as the producer has a strong economic incentive to apply additional techniques and boost production from a given property at higher gas prices.

Hugoton does not have a specified end date, but it would probably terminate if net profits collapsed for an extended period. To provide a perspective, between April 2018 and October 2020, the operating and development costs of Hugoton exceeded its revenues by a wide margin due to low gas prices. As a result, the trust suspended its distribution throughout that period.

Even worse, when the price of natural gas began to recover from the downturn caused by the pandemic, Hugoton did not reinstate its distribution, as it had to wait for its profits to offset the losses incurred during the downturn.

On July 2nd, 2021, Hugoton announced that it had agreed to be sold to XTO Energy for $6 million ($0.165 per unit) in cash. In the special meeting held on December 10th, 2021, the deal was not approved by unitholders.

The latter were very fortunate, as the above deal would have resulted in devastating losses for the vast majority of unitholders. To be sure, the price of the deal was about 90% lower than the price of the stock in the beginning of 2018.

Even better for the unitholders, two months after the rejection of the deal, the global gas market became extremely tight thanks to the sanctions of Europe and the U.S. on Russia for its invasion in Ukraine. Before this crisis, Russia was providing about one-third of natural gas consumed in Europe. Due to the sanctions, Europe was forced to import a record number of LNG cargos from the U.S. and thus the U.S. natural gas market became extremely tight. This led the U.S. gas prices to rally to a 13-year high. As a result, Hugoton resumed paying monthly distributions in August 2022, after more than four years without a single payment of distribution.

In mid-November, Hugoton reported (11/14/22) financial results for the third quarter of fiscal 2022. Its realized prices of oil and gas recovered strongly over the prior year’s quarter thanks to the aforementioned tailwind from the sanctions of western countries on Russia. As a result, even though the oil and gas output of the trust decreased, its distributable income per unit recovered from $0.00 to $0.22. It was the best quarterly performance of Hugoton since the third quarter of 2014.

Thanks to the exceptionally favorable gas prices which have prevailed this year, Hugoton has posted an 8-year high distributable cash flow per unit of $0.35. This distribution corresponds to an annualized distribution yield of 16.7% at the current stock price.

The sanctions of western countries on Russia are not likely to be withdrawn anytime soon and hence Hugoton is likely to keep thriving in the short run. However, it is important to keep in mind the extreme sensitivity of the trust to the cycles of the price of natural gas.

Due to a global economic slowdown in recent months and a record number of renewable energy projects being developed, the prices of oil and gas have plunged off their peak levels and are now hovering below their level just before the onset of the war in Ukraine. This is a strong bearish technical signal for oil and gas prices, as it essentially indicates that the global energy market has fully absorbed the impact of the Ukrainian crisis.

Growth Prospects

The biggest growth catalyst for Hugoton is rising oil and gas prices. Supportive commodity prices are critical for the trust’s ability to generate higher net profits, which yield higher distribution payouts. As oil and gas prices both rallied to multi-year highs in 2022, Hugoton posted blowout results and offered an 8-year high distribution this year.

However, the cash flows of Hugoton are highly cyclical due to the dramatic swings of the prices of oil and gas, which have resulted in a markedly volatile performance record. Moreover, the multi-year high oil and gas prices that have prevailed this year have caused a global energy crisis. Numerous people are striving to pay for their energy bills. Consequently, most countries are doing their best to transition from fossil fuels to renewable energy sources. To this end, there is a record number of clean energy projects under development right now. When all these projects come online, in 2-5 years, they will take their toll on the prices of oil and gas. This is a significant risk factor for Hugoton to keep in mind.

Given the high comparison base formed by the 8-year high distributable cash flow per unit of $0.35 this year, the natural decline of producing wells and the secular headwind of the global transition from fossil fuels to clean energy sources, we expect a 12.0% average annual decline of distributable cash flow per unit over the next five years.

Dividend Analysis

Hugoton Royalty Trust pays a monthly distribution. The record date each month is usually the 30th day. Distributions are paid no later than 17 calendar days after the monthly record date.

The distribution of Hugoton fluctuates depending on the direction of oil and gas prices. During favorable periods, the trust has distributed $0.50-$1.50 per unit annually. Thanks to favorable commodity prices, the trust has posted an 8-year high distribution this year.

The distribution history of Hugoton over the past 11 years is as follows:

• 2012 distributions of $0.58 per unit
• 2013 distributions of $0.86 per unit
• 2014 distributions of $1.10 per unit
• 2015 distributions of $0.19 per unit
• 2016 distributions of $0.05 per unit
• 2017 distributions of $0.11 per unit
• 2018 distributions of $0.01 per unit
• 2019 distributions of $0.00 per unit
• 2020 distributions of $0.00 per unit
• 2021 distributions of $0.00 per unit
• 2022 distributions of $0.35 per unit

During the last decade, Hugoton has offered an average distribution yield of only 4.3% to its unitholders. This yield is far lower than the average yield of the other oil and gas trusts. To be sure, Sabine Royalty Trust and Cross Timbers Royalty Trust have offered average distribution yields of 7.9% and 8.8%, respectively, over the last decade. The poor distribution yield of Hugoton has resulted primarily from the suspension of distributions between early 2018 and mid-2022.

Hugoton has distributed $0.35 per unit in 2022. This equates to a distribution yield of 16.7% at the current stock price. While this yield is certainly enticing, it is impossible to predict future distributions due to the unknown path of oil and gas prices.

On the bright side for the trust, the ongoing war between Russia and Ukraine has no end in sight and hence oil and gas prices are likely to remain above average in the short run. On the other hand, whenever this war comes to an end or the western countries loosen their sanctions, there will probably be a sharp correction in the prices of oil and gas. Given the multi-year high oil and gas prices that have prevailed in 2022, investors should expect much lower distributions from Hugoton in the long run, especially given the aforementioned secular shift of most countries from fossil fuels to renewable energy sources.

As the market is always a forward-looking mechanism, whenever the market focuses on the potential impact of all the clean energy projects under development on the energy market, the prices of oil and gas will probably incur a sharp decline. It is also important to note that oil and gas prices have already incurred a sharp correction off their multi-year highs and thus they are now trading below their level just before the Ukrainian crisis. While they are still hovering at above-average levels, they are likely to moderate even further in the upcoming years.

Final Thoughts

Royalty trusts like Hugoton are essentially a bet on commodity prices. Due to its pure upstream nature and its focus primarily on natural gas, the trust is extremely sensitive to the cycles of the price of natural gas.

If the price of natural gas remains around its current level for years, the assets of the trust could potentially be undervalued. However, we believe that oil and gas prices will enter another downcycle at some point in the future, just like they always have. Whenever the next downturn of the energy sector shows up, Hugoton will have significant downside risk while it will also reduce its distributions.

The suspension of distributions between early 2018 and mid-2022, the 95% plunge of the stock between 2018 and 2021 and the failed attempt of Hugoton to dissolve in 2021 are stern reminders of the excessive risk of this trust. If the trust experiences a prolonged downturn in the future, it may dissolve this time. Investors should be prepared for this risk and thus they should allocate a limited portion of their cash on this trust if they decide to include it in their portfolio.

High-risk stocks sometimes offer outsized profits but they can also cause devastating losses. In the long run, they usually underperform the broad market. During the last decade, Hugoton has dramatically underperformed the S&P 500, as it has plunged 73% whereas the index has rallied 161%. Overall, investors should carefully review the risks and unique considerations that go along with investing in volatile royalty trusts.

If you are interested in finding more high-quality dividend growth stocks suitable for long-term investment, the following Sure Dividend databases will be useful:

Thanks for reading this article. Please send any feedback, corrections, or questions to support@suredividend.com.


More from sure dividend
The Sure Dividend Investing MethodMember's Area